Cosimo's - <a href

Food is ok. Not the worst but not the greatest. They really need a waiting area as well

We had the worst experience last night and didn’t even make it passed the hostess stand. My parents are regulars at the Middletown location and refuse to go the Newburgh location and now I understand why. When we arrived there were 2 couples in the waiting area and we said we didn’t have a reservation and were told oh we don’t take reservations and it would be a 30 minute wait, understandable for a Friday night. Slowly people started coming giving the number of people in their party and instantl … – show

Honestly, my favorite restaurant to date they have the most delicious Italian food definitely worth every penny. Also, the service was amazing Milton best server worker ever.

Great place for a nice Birthday Dinner. Amazing Food and Amazing Service.

The food and service was excellent. Very friendly and attentive server I highly recommend this restaurant we had a party of 20 everybody was happy