Arethusa Farm Dairy - BANTAM

I love this place. Have for over 10 years. But the sudden disappearance of the unsalted butter will be traumatic during Christmas cookie season and I’m not sure I can forgive them..

My niece brought some home for a family get together and I gave the coconut with chocolate chunks a try. Fantastic! I was content with that until I’d be told to try to chocolate. I gave the chocolate a few bites. This is the best chocolate ice cream I’ve ever had in my entire life. Rich, creamy, it’s almost like it’s the full taste of chocolate and I’ve been eating it at volume 6 all these years. I decided to try the mint chip ice cream because there is no way they could get every flavor perfect. They did. I’m not sure who’s creating this ice cream but God gives us all something to offer and many never find their calling. This person has! I wish they sold this closer to me and am trying to find an excuse to drive up to Litchfield. Just wanted to share my thoughts as I have family that stops down from New Haven occasionally. They will get a list next time they’re coming for a visit. Great work, guys!

I love that the ice cream here has natural mix-ins (ex. strawberries, coconut flakes, almond pieces, chocolate chunks) rather than artificial flavors. The price is a bit steep, but fair given the huge amount of ice cream you get in 'one scoop. ' It 's so worth it!

The ice cream tasted great! Reminds me of UCONN dairy bar, just many less flavors. Got mint chip and sweet cream chocolate chunk. Both were great. Scoop sizes are enormous

1 scoop is the size of 2! Chocolate and strawberry flavors are amaziing