Which Wich Superior Sandwiches

First time ordering from here. Really happy with the accuracy, speed and quality of food!!!

I stopped by Witch Wich on a Sunday afternoon while out running errands. I was planning to get it yo go, but I changed my mind when I saw the welcoming environment and semi comfortable seating. I was immediately greeted and asked if I'd ever been there before. I think it was probably obvious that I hadn't because I walked right up to the counter, which is not how it's done. It's pretty cool, actually. You walk over to a table on the right and fill out a bag with your name and order on it. With my dairy allergy, I was advised to write that directly on the bag. That bag became my order ticket and the bag my sandwich was put in! Cool, right? Especially for my dairy allergy! Anyway, I ordered the California Club with water and fries. I was immediately impressed by how quickly the food was done. The fries were served in a cup with foil over it, which kept them super hot. I ate half of them before I even touched my sandwich because they were so good and hot. When I tried my sandwich, I had two problems. 1. They forgot the avacado and 2. The bread was quite crispy, but that might be personal preference. A very kind employee offered to remake the sandwich for me, but of course, I told them that wasn't necessary. They could just give me the avacado, and that worked fine. All in all, I'll probably give back. They had a great allergy menu online and a lot of different kinds of sandwiches. I might ask for the bread to be lightly toasted though.

Great service, friendly staff and very tasty sandwiches! Will definitely return!

Overpriced and underwhelming. I ordered for the first time tonight and it will be the last.I ordered a hot Turkey sub and a side of fries. 12 bucks for a small sub that had two measly slices of Turkey on it and also undercooked fries. I got ranch with the fries and I couldn’t even eat the ranch. It tasted cheap and disgusting. Never again. Next time I’ll go to Penn Station or Jimmy Johns. Cheaper and much more appetizing.

This is a smaller store so not much for eating in. They are extremely pricey.Their menus are HORRIBLE! They don't explain what most of the sandwiches are. There are no prices listed until you start placing an order. The store was out of some of the condiments.We spent $36 for two people for two medium sized sandwiches, two small fries and only one drink.