Benny's Italian Eatery

Love this place. The guys are friendly, service is always fast and food is delicious. Can’t beat that!

Every time I go there I get something different and they have not let me down not in the littlest way these guys are the best

I never expected to find the best traditional pizza in the small town of Boiling Springs, PA. The dough recipe is spot on, earning this pizzeria a perfect 5-star rating. This cozy little restaurant will exceed your expectations. Bravo, Benny's. Bravo.

Food is good, guys are super friendly and on Fridays it's busy but they're always so pleasant. Glad they have a GF pizza option as well as GF sub rolls thank you! Usually our order is correct but last visit (on an incredibly busy Friday evening) we got a wrong sub. This is the first time out of a bunch of visits so we'll chalk it up to an honest mistake due to being busy and it won't prevent us from ordering again. Not much room inside to sit, so plan on doing take out.

This was our first time dining at Benny's, and we will definitely be returning! The pizza was incredible, especially the crust.