Cardinali Bakery Pastry Shop

Still on my quest to find the best strawberry shortcake on LI. There’s a lot of well known popular bakeries on LI that make stale cakes, this bakery is the first cake that isn’t stale which is a huge plus in my book.This strawberry shortcake is 9.0/10Buttercream frosting perfect amount of sweetness, and perfect amount of fluff.Sponge layer cake right amount of moisture. The picture looks like it’s dry but it isn’t. Could be slightly more spongy.Strawberry filling It’s a bit too sweet and bit too thick. I’d say make it 10% less sweet and 15% less thick to make this cake perfect.

Accidentally found gem--fabulous in every way! The day before Easter, I tried to pick up a lemon meringue pie that I thought I ordered there. I actually ordered it from another bakery. The owner could not have been nicer to me despite my annoyed demeanor and him believing I likely had the wrong place. He made the pie just for me and delivered it to my house an hour and a half later. Everything looked and smelled incredibly delicious; and, their kindness went above and beyond. It was obvious to me that they care about their products and their customers very much. I sent my son there for a fruit tart the next day. It was exceptional. I have been there since and plan to go there often although it is not local for me. The bread has that special crisped finish that only happens when baked in a brick oven. It and the other items I purchased were wonderful. Don't miss trying this lovely shop with old-world charm. Thank you to everyone there.

I recently had the pleasure of visiting Cardinali Bakery and I must say, it was an absolutely delightful experience. From the moment I walked in, I was greeted with the most delicious smells of freshly baked bread and pastries. The atmosphere was warm and inviting, with friendly staff who were more than happy to help me choose from the wide range of treats on offer. I would highly recommend Cardinali Bakery to anyone looking for delicious, high-quality baked goods and exceptional customer service. I will definitely be returning to this wonderful bakery again and again!

The truth always comes to lightYour bread is at my dinner tableIt's one of the best I have ever hadMy family my kids love your stuffIt's the only bread that yoi can count in that taste the way from 90s when we were kids if I have. It made my point clear your breat will be part of my family for years to come your cookies are awaome the staff rocks there always so friendly I have my favs that work in the store to cardinal we love you stuff

I think the pastries are amazing and the cookies delicious like a old time Italian bakery BUT everytime I go I am charged differently for the cookies by the pound the girl I had today was so rude and short with me. A short girl with a ponytail dark hair have some patience your dealing with customers it's called customer service.