Tomaso's Italian American - Cedarburg

It’s always a pleasure to eat here. Even after a festival day, we only had to wait about 20-30 minutes to be seated. We’ve always loved their pizza for takeout, so we decided it was time to try their pasta. My daughter devoured her kids’ spaghetti with red sauce, and my wife and I thoroughly enjoyed our specialty pasta dishes. My wife had the spicy chicken and spinach cavatappi, which was packed with flavor, spice, meat, and just the right amount of sauce. I opted for the chicken carbonara, which came with mushrooms, onions, bacon, and a delicious cream sauce that wasn’t too heavy or rich. For the price, this place offers a fantastic dining experience with a friendly atmosphere.

I had a slice of pizza at Harvestfest, and it was absolutely amazing! Both my wife and I are completely hooked. From the very first bite, we knew we had to return. The cheese, toppings, crust, and sauce were all perfect.

This is our favorite thin crust pizza in town! Think fruit on pizza is weird? I suggest you give it a try before you pass judgment.

My dad and I have been coming to Tomaso's for 30 years plus. It is as good today as it was the first time we came way back when. I would recommend the deep dish, it is absolutely outstanding!

We have been to Tomaso's in Cedarburg many times and enjoyed it. Small, cozy and never minded ordering at the bar. However, we visited recently and the pizza we received was really spicy, not at all like what we had in the past. In fact, we couldn't eveneat it. We went to tell the bartender and he insisted it's been the same for years and wouldn't even listen to us. Reallyrude. He said he was one of the owners. We won't be back again.