Rusty Bucket And Tavern - Columbus

The food was cooked exactly as requested, service was quick and friendly, the atmosphere was pleasant. We chose to sit on the patio because the weather was nice. The only negative was that someone at the table next to us was smoking which is notpermitted in the state of Ohio. It was very obvious but the staff didn't intervene.

My boyfriend and I really enjoy visiting this place. The atmosphere is warm and cozy, and the bartenders and waitstaff are incredibly friendly. I particularly love the French onion soup, while my boyfriend is a big fan of the meatloaf!

I visited the restaurant for dinner on a Saturday night with my boyfriend. It was quite busy, but we were seated quickly, and a waitress even complimented us. However, we waited about 45 minutes after being seated before a waiter came to greet us, and no one attended to us during that time. While I understand that a larger group was seated next to us, it was frustrating to see two other couples arrive after us and receive their food before we did. I've always enjoyed the food here, but this time I was disappointed with the service.

My husband and I visited this restaurant for dinner tonight to celebrate our anniversary, not expecting to find a spot this year. Luckily, we were able to snag a last-minute reservation, and we were warmly attended to by the front-of-house manager, Katie. Despite the restaurant being quite busy and the kitchen facing some challenges, Katie was actively working with all the tables to ensure everyone had a pleasant evening. She stopped by our table several times to check on us, and I truly appreciated her hospitality. Katie, you made our night incredibly enjoyable, and we are grateful for your efforts. Thank you!

How does one justify a five star review? Was the food the best I'be ever had? Of course not, but it was very good, well in line with the price point. The service was attentive and on the spot. The atmosphere was pleasant and conducive to enjoying themeal. (NOTE: I now must return in the winter to enjoy the fireplace! Even the restroom was immaculate.