Rusty Bucket And Tavern - Columbus

The food was cooked exactly as requested, service was quick and friendly, the atmosphere was pleasant. We chose to sit on the patio because the weather was nice. The only negative was that someone at the table next to us was smoking which is notpermitted in the state of Ohio. It was very obvious but the staff didn't intervene.

How does one justify a five star review? Was the food the best I'be ever had? Of course not, but it was very good, well in line with the price point. The service was attentive and on the spot. The atmosphere was pleasant and conducive to enjoying themeal. (NOTE: I now must return in the winter to enjoy the fireplace! Even the restroom was immaculate.

Consistently Good. I've been to the Bexley location five times or so in the last year, and haven't been disappointed yet. Its always good food, and usually good service. I absolutely love their pulled brisket nachos, they are a heaping mound of everything that is bad for you to eat (at least its real cheese). The Bucket may not overwhelm you with awesomeness, but they have a solid menu with enough options for everyone to find what they are looking for, and its not a bad place to catch a game (even have TVs in the bathroom so you don't miss any of the action).

Love the chili, which makes the Gary's Three-Way my favorite, too. And, Double Nickel salads taste great; throwback to the old 55 Restaurants. I do hold the red onions, though--a bit too potent for my liking. And, has my favorite beers and decent wine.

Best veggie burger. I've tried a lot of veggie burgers around town, but this one is my absolute favorite.