Vinnie's New York Pizzeria - Cottonwood

The chicken, bacon, and ranch pizza was delicious! However, the restaurant was quite noisy.

I have always loved Vinnie’s pizza! And they are reliable and have always had delicious NY pizza. The delivery gentleman named Jake has always been on time and very nice! Somebody give that man a raise! Thanks!

We ordered the large Supreme pizza, and while it was tasty, we found it lacking in toppings—just one slice of pepperoni and a few small bits of sausage per slice for a $24 pizza felt quite overpriced! We won’t be ordering pizza from there again.

Counter people were a little flustered and out of it and the tables were dirty, but the pizza is great so we'll be back.

I decided to order a Hawaiian pizza, which I usually avoid because, let's be honest, it's not really pizza. Unfortunately, it had very little sauce and lacked flavor. We then opted for a supreme pizza, but it turned out the same way—barely any sauce, a soggy center, and a doughy crust.