Sarah's Creamery - Dover

Nice place. Cost more than other places but big scoops. Nice play area kids.

So I would be giving 5 stars if it wasn't for the high prices and terrible rewards. I've been going to Sarah's like once a week with different family members visiting and we all 3 always get larges which I believe ran us close to 8 dollars which was okay because it's amazing ice cream and a cute little shop that smells like vanilla, but after spending close to 80 dollars I feel like something better than 2 dollars off my next 8 dollar ice cream should be offered. After realizing it wasn't a free small or medium and it was just 2 dollars off, I haven't been back. We tried macks which wasn't nearly as tasty but it also was half the price ‍ Cookie Monster is literally the only flavor I ever get because it's so freaking good. I'd be giving 5 stars if it wasn't for not getting something better for spending so much money all the time.

Ice cream is good. Ordered a shake through Greer's next door from here. Had to wait in the Sarah's line for 30-40 minutes for the ONE employee on duty to turn around and take the already made shake out of a fridge. I mean come on. That long a wait to retrieve an already paid and made product? I know Greer's is its own place and the coordination can be hard but between two businesses find another solution than waiting in another line as your food gets cold. Absolutely ridiculous. You gotta find a better way.

This is a beautiful little town ice business that they really like. the atmosphere, the personal and above all the iron out of penn state is great. they have free games like maisloch out and many others inside. I also love the outdoor and terrace.

Nice little place. friendly service. choice of penn state cream or handmade ices.