Old Stone Market - East Hampton

This is a jewel of a market! Great for picking up ingredients or things you need for an impromptu picnic or dinner. Lunch is great! Empanadas are so good. But I really came here to rave over the peanut butter cookies. If you get them when they are fresh, do not walk.

It’s hard to decide what’s best here, but I guarantee you won’t find better scones elsewhere; the English cream in particular. The list of delicious foods goes on. We tried almost everything: the chicken cutlets, crispy yet juicy; the soups, particularly the Mexican one they have, and I don’t exaggerate when I say I could eat that for lunch and dinner three days back to back; the lasagna and the chicken pot pie are full of flavor with the unmistakable taste of homemade cooking. The cheese cake is to die-for and the rice pudding became a ritual for us when we are in Amagansett. If you are around, and haven’t discovered this place, GO!

The food here is fantastic, especially the homemade dishes, and they have an excellent variety of baked goods. It's a small business with an unusual layout, but it's warm and inviting. While the staff could be a bit friendlier, it's still a worthwhile place to visit.

The food is fantastic and the service is friendly. The owner, Vicky, is an amazing cook. Her baked goods are both delicious and always fresh. If you're in the area, you should definitely stop by this place. It's a great spot for good food, and the market has a bit of everything.

I ordered a bacon, egg, and cheese on a Kaiser roll. Getting a perfectly cooked over-easy egg can be tough, but this place met my expectations for a messy breakfast sandwich. The refrigerator had some intriguing options, as you can see in the photo I posted.