The Quiet Clam 2.0 - East Hampton

Ate here last night and had a terrific meal. I don't get the negative reviews for this place unless it just had growing pains in the beginning. Service was super friendly and attentive. I had one of the best margaritas I have ever had--not too sweet and made with fresh lime juice (and big). The cornmeal-fried calimari was delicious with added various peppers and tomatoes also fried in cornmeal. The fish tacos were a hearty portion and amazing with some kind of sauce or salsa that was memorable. My husband enjoyed the the artichokes and a fish and chips special. Atmosphere is casual and friendly. Added bonus was that the prices are very reasonable. I spent double at Nick and Toni's last week for a very mediocre meal. I hope this restaurant sticks around because it is going to become our next go to.

We have been to this restaurant 3 times since they opened before this visit. We like the old menu and were very disappointed with the new menu. The Cesar salad was half a romaine with a few corn kernels and sprinkle of powdered cheese. My husband enjoyed his oyster po boy which was a special. My martini was good. We won’t be back unless they add be knour favorites: seafood over pasta and tuna. Randi M

Loved this restaurant...had the linguine with clam sauce ...very good...friend had fish and chips...over fried, as where the fried calamari...please watch this..could be an Achilles heel if it gets around that you guys over- fry your fried dish...I’ll be back...service was great by the way

Delicious fish tacos and lobster roll! Great little spot right on Montauk Hwy.

Portions were TINY!!! 8 steamers in an order. Seriously, we counted! Ordered that and artichoke for 3. Tasty but way too skimpy. We actually told the waiter we were starving. You would think he would have said order more. The special blackened mahi mahi was also teeny tiny (smaller than my small iPhone) and COMPLETELY tasteless. Waiter’s answer was to bring us hot sauce. Did I mention for this poorly seasoned food and tiny portions it was really expensive. Needless to say, not even giving it a second chance