Johnny's Paradise Pizza

Great prices. I'll go there a week. Never a free disk. If I had a five star.

I come all the way from Commack to eat this food. It is the best around! And the staff is friendly and helpful and generous! Try the baked ziti, it is terrific!

Best pizza around! Super friendly staff and they get your pizza ready very quick!

In my opinion, this is the best pizzeria on the island, especially if you're a pizza enthusiast like I am. The stuffed pizzas are massive, so be prepared to share! The selection of pizza options is truly impressive. Make sure to try the mac and cheese pizza. We visited late on a Sunday night, and everything we wanted was readily available. The prices are very reasonable, and everything tastes amazing, leaving us with plenty of leftovers. I no longer live nearby, but whenever I'm in the area, I always make a point to stop by Paradise Pizza!

This place has the best Eggplant Parmesan and Lasagna I've ever had. The service is always polite and friendly, whether you're there in person or ordering over the phone, and the delivery is quick. The sauce reminds me of my grandma's, which brings back wonderful memories.