Fratelli's Bagel Express

Their bagels and breakfast sandwiches are simply amazing! The bagels are HUGE and they have a ton of different options. (Don't forget cream cheese to go!!!

I ordered a mushroom panini and a bagel with one of those birthday cake kind of cream cheese. They both wear super super awesome. I will definitely go back here for the lunch. That was friendly and the restaurant was nice and clean. What a great lunch I had.

I stopped by quickly on my way to the Port Jefferson ferry. This restaurant is amazing with delicious bagels (I tried an everything bagel with bacon, egg, and cheese) and fast service. There is plenty of indoor seating and some outdoor seating as well. The bathroom was clean too.

I had to give this restaurant a one-star rating. The bagels are incredibly sweet, especially when eaten plain. They seem to be much higher in calories than typical bagels, tasting more like a dessert than a bread. They leave a noticeable artificial sweetener aftertaste. They may resemble bagels in appearance, but they definitely do not taste like traditional bagels.

I have noticed an increasing number of 1-star reviews, and after reading them, I understand why. Many customers have complained about the rude staff at this restaurant. My fiancée and I moved to New York a few years ago and have always enjoyed having breakfast at Bagel Express occasionally. The owner is very nice. However, when my fiancée went to pick up two dozen bagels for our Thanksgiving gathering, she encountered a negative experience. Despite arriving early to ensure there were enough bagels, the guy behind the counter gave her a nasty look and made a sarcastic comment to another customer about "out of towners." Although my fiancée handled the situation politely, it was still hurtful. As a result, we will no longer be recommending Bagel Express.