Brooklyn Pizza - Edgewater

I have a deep fondness for this place, as my family used to visit regularly in the past, and I recently returned to find it just as wonderful as I remembered. The pizza features a deliciously charred crust that is simply outstanding. The prices for the pizzas are very reasonable. The appetizers are quite generous, especially the roasted mozzarella, which is one of only two places in the area that serve it this way. I tried their classic Margherita pizza, and it was excellent in terms of quality. I’m looking forward to bringing some friends here in a few weeks. The only downside is that they only accept cash, which makes it a little inconvenient. However, it's definitely worth it!

The perfect family-friendly restaurant! We ordered the antipasto salad, a large pizza with pepper salad on one half, penne pasta with Italian sauce, and tarte au chocolat for dessert. It was some of the best food I've had since moving to NJ from Brooklyn three years ago—absolutely delicious! The atmosphere is relaxing and comfortable, and the service is attentive. This place is a gem, and it's definitely going to be a regular spot for our family.

No pizza is truly unforgettable, right? Well, you haven’t been to this place! I’ll remember it for the rest of my life. WOW, this place was amazing!!!!

We've been here for years. We get the white pizza with sausage, marinara sauce on the side and Calamari. The food is consistently good, like the service. Only cash.

Ordered a pepperoni pie here and it was great, really good pizza. Walked in and pie was ready in 15 minutes. Orfered a small pie but even so it seemed like a large pie. Place has a number of tables inside for sit down dining. Was impressed at how fast my pizza was made and wasn't that expensive either. Highly recommend getting pizza here!