Papa Johns Pizza - Ellettsville

This is absolutely the best Papa John’s we have ever gotten Pizza from!!!! They make it the same(Delicious!!!)every single time we order!!! Thank you for being awesome!!!

They were swamped. New Years Eve, which was understandable. I'm very patient and understanding, though. The Papa tracker was off. It's probably due to the number of orders coming in. The gal with the pixie cut blue hair was super friendly and made me feel relaxed and welcome. Even with as busy as they were. My only issue was that we requested the pizzas all well done. They were far from it. I understand they are stressed and pressed for time. It was not a huge deal, but it's how we like our pizzas done. Other than that, it was really good. I would definitely order Papa John's in Ellettsville again.

We love Papa John’s and order frequently. We did want to let you know that when our pizza arrived tonight, it looked like it had been involved in a hit and run. We understand things can’t always be perfect and will continue to be loyal customers. We just thought you want to know. It was still delicious!!

We are new to the area from Indianapolis.We typically order Papa John's weekly. Our 1st experience to the Ellettsville location was outstanding. Upon arrival we were greeted with a smile by Aaron and food was grrrreat. We will definitely be back on a regular basis :

Best pizza in Ellettsville!Pizza is always amazing and they definitely have the best deals in town! They rarely make mistakes. However, our last order, they forgot the extra dipping sauces we ordered. When we went back to pick them up, they were super nice and gave us extra ones for our trouble. That was definitely enough to make up for it but they went a step further, a few days later we got a coupon for a free medium size cheese pizza for the mistake, great company...great pizza.