Mueller's Pizza - Feedback

Love their pizza! Getting pizza here has been a family tradition since before I was born. I come all the way from southeastern PA every year to visit family and...

Service: Takeout Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $20–30

Gretchen is always working hard . As long as I have been coming here she has ALWAYS been my server. Never had a bad experience here! Great food, awesome service...

Kid-friendliness: Kids adore this place—it has a retro vibe and a jukebox for fun. Service: Takeout Meal type: Dinner

The pizza was great! Thin, crispy crust with plenty of cheese and topppings! Server was very friendly and attentive. Great find! Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere:...

I can't comment on the service or the food because every time I tried to place an order, someone answered the phone and then hung up right away.

Depends on how you like pizza…. The sauce is strong, with good flavors. They cut the pizza into Squares pieces, which drive some ppl crazy, lol. Give it a try,...

The crust is crispy and has a delicious smokeyness to it. Being a Wisconsin native, I can tell you this is an absolutely 100% Grade A+ fantastic mozzarella chee...

Worst pizza I've ever had! Won't b ordering ever again! Tastes like burnt plastic and was scolding hot when brought to me.

This place has been a favorite for decades. I always visit when I’m in town. Please don’t pay attention to the negative reviews because they are highly inaccura...

Excellent experience! The service is friendly, and the food has been fantastic since I first visited in the 1980s. The Gyro sandwich is delicious, and their piz...

What a fantastic local pizza spot! The crust was thin and crispy, and it was loaded with cheese. A real gem in the Northwoods!

My order was incorrect; I got mozzarella sticks instead of pizza sticks. However, I don’t really mind because they were delivered in just 15 minutes, which make...

Delicious cake! They stay open later than all the other places, and the service is quick thanks to the one lady working the night shift!

I've been eating Mueller's pizza for over 35 years and it never gets old.