Peyton's Pie Company - Flowery Branch

The first visit was superb (I think the owner was cooking). We had the wings in Alabama sauce, the tomato soup, and Peyton's Pie. The 2nd visit was just okay. Not as good as the first at all: two young guys cooking, not the owner. We had the same wings (just okay), tomato soup (still pretty good), and a Pig and Olives pizza (slightly below average). Waitress: very nice/attentive both time. Just disappointed by the lack of consistent quality/flavor.

If I could give this place 10 stars I would.Everything from the atmosphere, customer service and of course food was amazing.Perfect little spot in Flowery Branch.Fresh ingredients makes this place to die for.Crispy fall off the bone wings.Buttery crispy perfect pizza. Meaty tender mushrooms and rosemary oil with basil is just such an amazing treat for you mouth, nose and belly!Friendly and fun staff made me feel like a member of a family.Please if you're in the area give this place a try. You will be happy you did.I'm going back for the pot pie next!

Service was quick, small seating area but nice atmosphere, pizza was great. Reminds me of a NY style pizza.

This is some of the pizza I've ever ate. The sauce is delicious and the crust is killer. You can definitely taste the wood fired oven in the crust. I would definitely recommend Peyton's Pie Company and we will be back again.

Amazing atmosphere and food. A truly great authentic Italian style pizza made with a proper matured and proofed dough that is light and gentle on your stomach with premium quality toppings!