Peppy's Pizza Subs - Fredericktown

Cute small town eatery. Has a lot of Fredericktown HS sports memorabilia like letterman jackets and old year books that you can look through while waiting. Their wings are AMAZING too!

Not sure where the sauce went on there pizza. We have bought Peppy's for over 40 years and this was never a problem. Now there's no sauce and only a few pepperoni. Will be awhile before we order again.

I used to love coming here but that all changed from a very poor experience! I called and ordered a small pepperoni calzone and cheesy bread when I got there a guy who I believe was named gavin said I ordered a small pepperoni pizza I told him I wanted a small pepperoni calzone he didnt seem very apologetic about his mistake all I got as a response was uh sorry dude I get it mistakes happen but they shouldve done better they said they would make me a calzone real quick but it took forever! Something that shouldve took 20 mins ended up taking 90 mins unacceptable! I 'm never coming back I encourage you to take your business to pizza dock!

I used to love coming here but not anymore! Your service has gone downhill bad the last time I was there I had to wait 90 mins for something that was promised to be done in 20 mins I get it mistakes happened but they did nothing to make it right with me! All I got was uh sorry dude from the cashier from a guy who I believe was named Gavin but I cant remember his name since the incident took place 3 months ago regardless of the time it took place it 's completely unacceptable! I 'm never coming back I encourage you to take your business down the road to pizza dock!

Years ago we loved getting pizza from here. Recently within the past year the service and food has gone downhill fast. We went in to get pizza months ago and the lady was grinding her gums like she was on pills or drugs. She was nodding her head. We got home and it looked like a 4 year old tried to cut our pizzas. We stayed away for a while and went to give them another chance and it was essentially the same. The price of pizza is also high for the quality. The owners really should reconsider who they hire.