Coffaros' Pizza - Grove City

I ordered lunch on two different occasions, and both times the delivery was late. I wouldn't recommend this place. When I attempted to reach out to them, I was put on hold and couldn't speak to a live representative.

Honestly, this is the best pizza I've had in a long time! The cheesy breadsticks are simply incredible, and the chicken bacon ranch pizza is the best I've ever tasted from anywhere! The customer service is consistently outstanding, and the delivery drivers are always so friendly. Our pizzas are always delivered or picked up hot, fresh, and perfectly cooked! They definitely don't skimp on the toppings either! My boyfriend and I probably won't order pizza from anywhere else in Grove City again, and we've made it a weekly tradition to order from here. Plus, it makes me really happy that they're open later than all the other pizza places around!

When you ask for extra sauce and cheese you get lite cheese and sauce slopped on top of the cheese

Awesome and friendly as you can get. The calzones are huge, great sauce and fresh as it gets. The dough is fresh and easy to tell its a hometown diamond in the rough. Definitely will be a steady customer moving forward. Also they sell by the slice...perfect for a fast bite!!!

Pizza not worth 1 star. Picked up a pizza on my way home Friday night, when I ordered it I was told 30-35 minutes before it would be ready. In 25 minutes I picked up a COLD, OVERDONE pizza. Crust was harder than the box it came in, when I asked how early I should have been there to avoid it being placed on top of the oven, I was told just depended on how busy they were, no time frame was given. If this was 1st time I would make an exception but it has happened at least 3 times, needless to say we will go elsewhere for our pie.