Godfather's Pizza - Hastings

A delivery order, first ordered with Godfather, had to ask what the peculiarities were, no suggestive sale. Did not tell me the amount of my order before he asked me my payment information, very unprofessional. Good thing I had a great supplier. You have to work on phone skills.

Every pizza I had at Godfather's was absolutely perfect! From the flavors to the crust, everything was spot on! Great job, Mike Glassmyer, and your whole team! I would recommend it to everyone! The cakes are delicious all day long! It is a bit pricey, but considering the quality you receive, it’s definitely worth it! Not a single pizza has disappointed, and they are cooked perfectly every time! Thank you to Mike and his crew! Keep up the amazing work!

I absolutely love their pizza; it's one of my favorites in town! While it may be on the pricier side, they do offer some fantastic deals during the week. I recently ordered a pizza for delivery, and the person on the phone was nice and friendly. However, they should definitely make it a point to communicate the total amount before I have to provide my card details. When I asked for the total, it turned out to be more than I was willing to spend, so he had to go back and start over. He didn't seem upset, but he also didn't inform me of the new total. Overall, I'm a big fan of their pizza and the location is quite convenient. They just need to improve on communicating the totals.

I was quite surprised to discover a pizza buffet located in the middle of a gas station, along with a couple of other restaurants. It felt unusual, but I absolutely loved this place! The people who work there truly made it special. As for the meatballs, I’ve had my fair share over the years, but I can confidently say these are the BEST I’ve ever tasted! When I return to Hastings, I know exactly what I'll be ordering: those meatballs. The flavor was unlike anything I’ve experienced before—just perfect! The friendly staff is another reason this place stands out; they even mentioned wishing there was a location like this in Ohio! God bless!