Americano Pie Bar - Islip

I came here before a movie and it was great. It's very trendy inside with a huge bar. Our server was really nice and provided some great recommendations. We ordered the: truffolini, honey spice pizza, penne firenze, and Oreo cheesecake. The truffolini had pear in it and was delicious. We liked the pizza but have had better (still really good though). The penne firenze wasn't anything special, definitely a dish you can make at home. The Oreo cheesecake was really good too. Overall, I'd definitely recommend trying Americano Pie Bar.

A Tuesday night birthday dinner with a friend and while we've ordered take-out many times and like the food, weren't always game to dine in with the crowds and service but Jules and Eddie changed our minds moving forward. These two young people were so attentive and kind that they elevated our evening. These are the people you want customer facing in you establishment. Thanks, Jules and Eddie, for your great service and adding your smiles and conversation to our celebration!

Pretty authentic good food the lighting is absolutely perfect. And I really like that.

Beautiful restaurant right in the heart of Islip. Service and food will not disappoint. Highly recommend the Truffle Faggotini stuffed with pears...its to die for!!!

This review is based on a delivery order 4/5 only bc when I called after trying all the food and how delicious it was, whoever answered the phone seemed to not care and not want to talk bc when I told them I was calling to compliment them on the food I got a “okay?” I was trying to tell them how good the food was and that I look forward to eating there in person I got “okay.” “yeah sure” “okay. Have a good night.” absolutely terrible on the phone. No “I’m glad you enjoyed the food” or even a “thank you for the compliment but is there anything you need help with?” Just seemed to not wanna be there or talk on the phone. Whoever was answering the phone tonight, 10/19, should be a bus boy bc they clearly don’t know how to interact with customers.