Peepers - Kelleys Island

Rarely things live the expectations, but Peeper's whole damn barbecue did this and more. I visited 2020 and saw this on the menu, but there were 2 of us. For a whole year I thought about going back and we finally made it. Every part of the dinner was amazing. People were super friendly (and the dog) and the value was excellent. If you're hungry, that's for you

I had the Philly cheese Steak Brisket who was great. I had so much meat that the sandwich fell apart! But you have to order the right things. I ate with my mother and she has the burned ends... It was tender, but very salty and strange tasting. The drinks had a slightly cleaner taste, so it is best to stay with a slightly stronger tasting like the pink lemonade. Service was friendly, but could have been a tad faster as we were the only family in the restaurant then.

G was wonderful. I was with a Canadian person who said she was the nicest person she met. So I suppose that really says something.

The food is amazing. Excellent bbq and breakfast. Over a two night stay on Kelley's Island, we ate here three times and didn't want to try any other place. I can't wait to eat here again!

This restaurant offers the best food on the island. I highly recommend the chicken drum lollipops and the sirloin kabobs. They also serve the best beans I've ever tasted. Enjoy sitting on the veranda with a beer while watching people pass by. The owners and staff are fantastic!