The Courthouse Deli Whit's Frozen Custard

Terrible experience. I ordered a basic ham and cheese sandwich with tomato and lettuce, but received it without any lettuce or tomato, just two thin slices of ham. Subway offers more meat on their sandwiches than this place does. They charged $8.50 for this sandwich, which is not worth it. I recommend skipping this restaurant; there are much better options in Key West.

This restaurant has something for everyone! It's perfect for those looking for a quick bite. They have a coffee bar with a great selection of drinks and cold custard. We tried the milkshakes and coffee while heading to the Hemingway Museum. If you're planning to do the same, be sure to grab a size that you can finish during your walk, as drinks aren’t allowed inside the museum. We'll definitely return the next time we're in the area.

This place is fantastic! The staff is always friendly, and they offer custard samples. It's one of the few, if not the only, spots on the island serving custard. We love getting their roasted chicken sandwiches; you'll never be let down. Today, we were treated to custard samples, which was an added bonus!

This is a fantastic spot for deli and Cuban sandwiches. They also offer ice cream and frozen custard. It's a cozy little location with a selection of drinks, beer, and wine. The service is quick, the sandwiches are delicious, and the staff is very friendly. I’ll definitely be back soon!

We had made a custom Custard cake from them and it was fantastic! Honestly, the best custom Custard cake I've ever had. River makes everything you want, like a dream. I had done 3 custom Custard cakes from him and all 3 were heavenly. He really loves what he does and he does a great job!!