Sarah's Diner - La Crete

This place is amazing! I overheard a mother at the Dollar Tree recommending it to me when I asked the cashier for good restaurants. I'm so glad she did! The food was incredible, and the milkshake was the best I've ever had. The prices are perfect for the quality and quantity of the food they serve!

This restaurant operates like a well-oiled machine, serving affordable and delicious diner food promptly. The burgers are great, and the onion rings are absolutely mouthwatering. My favorite is the zucchini fries. The chili cheese fries make for a fantastic late-night snack. I'll definitely return next time. They closed 15 minutes earlier than expected, which I can now understand. The staff is very efficient and helpful. The decor is really cool, but since I visited at night, it was challenging to get good pictures.

When we went back to the counter to correct the order, the cashier had mistakenly taken my order incorrectly. I also ordered two cups of cheese but never received them. The manager, who I assume was the owner, was indifferent and didn’t make eye contact. Instead of apologizing, she pointed out that my order didn’t specify bacon and seemed to downplay the issue, even though the service was lackluster. The staff member serving us was unprofessional and dismissive. They eventually brought out a second burger, but it was just a turkey burger with cheese and no bacon. It was the same cold piece from the first order, having been passed around among several employees. It was also contaminated by the tomatoes, which were part of the original mix-up. We asked for a replacement. We finally received the correct order, but by then it was clear that it had been hastily prepared. The bacon looked unappetizing, as if it had been found in the trash. I know what good bacon should look like. What made matters worse was the manager's lack of concern; there was no apology for our wait or for the repeated mistakes. She avoided eye contact and seemed to want to rush away. The hassle and inconvenience we faced were unacceptable, and I feel compelled to share this experience with everyone I know to ensure they don’t bring their families here for a nice meal. When we finally managed to eat, the food was cold, and the whole afternoon was ruined. I don’t mind that the order was wrong—mistakes happen—but the rude nature of the interaction made it clear that this place is overpriced and more focused on luring in tourists than providing quality food and service. I suggest skipping this restaurant and supporting local establishments that value their customers and take pride in their food.

We discovered this restaurant on the way to the park and decided that it would be our lunch break on the way out. sara is not disappointed. large burger, tweepering rings and zucchini frit. quirky decoration really adds the experience.

A definite must place visit to eat!! The support the locals give this place is unbelievable. Only opened from April 1-end of September. If the weather is nice on opening day, the amount of cars in line to visit stretches up the hill past Waldameer. Wouldn’t be uncommon to wait up to an hour before you get into the lot. The food is delicious especially the homemade onion rings. Don’t forget to get the famous orange creamsicle ice cream cone!!!