Goodfellas Pizzeria Mill Street - Feedback

Great pizza...big vibes...small flop. airy crust..worth the stop to fill the search. completely agree with the portnoy scale....7.7

Come for the food, stay for the service. Not only is this pizza outstanding, they take such good care of their customers. It’s a treat coming here when visiting...

My wife and I dropped into Lexington for a short visit. Our first night was during Lexington 's Thursday Night Live on a closed-off down-town street with live m...

Fantastic pizza... I would highly recommend it to anyone! There will be a line and it's there for a reason! If you want the meatball sub, call ahead...

Best pizza EVER! I love pizza, but typically only eat on derby day, it's my ritual. I braved UK graduation traffic to get my Goodfellas from Mill Street. Yes, I...

A super authentic, and absolutely delicious as well, New York City style, pizza lovers experience... Wow!!! Everything they have is wonderful, you won't forget...

The pizza was so good! We ended up going back and taking a whole pie back to Tennessee with us!

Got a large pepperoni. This was the biggest pizza I've ever seen in ma life. I originally thought my bf said $48 bucks, and almost had a heart attack, but it wa...

Goodfellas pizza is amazing! It's one of the best pizzas I've ever had! If you've never had it, you should give it a try.

Friendly staff. Great food! Got a calzone it was big enough for 2 people. The bread stick was huge as well. Highly recommend.