Timothy Jay Sweets - Millbury

Tim has made TWO gorgeous cakes for me now- One fun gender reveal cake for my daughter in 2022 and recently made a custom safari themed cake for her 1st birthday. Cakes always taste amazing too!! We always snag a cupcake or cookie every time we swing through too. Highly recommend the funfetti flavor for the cakes! Thank you!

We ordered cupcakes. The icing tasted funny and hard. The cupcakes tasted very dry and hard. Everyone don't like it.

I ordered a gluten free cake for my son's baptism and it was SO delicious! Everyone kept asking where it was from and were surprised to find out it was gluten free. Everyone at Timothy Jay Sweets are so friendly and were so great to work with. Will definitely be back for future cake/dessert orders!

My first time there and it was an amazing experience. The shop it super cute and has so many treats to pick from! The owner was extremely nice and such a whole hearted individual. I would 100% go just to support him. But the peanut butter cookies were amazing and the chocolate bombs are fantastic. I honestly love this shop so much and this world needs more Tim’s.

I went there for the first time today. I got two of the salted caramel cupcakes. Let’s just say yummy, absolutely delicious. I was going to share with my husband but that’s definitely not happening now. I am actually glad he fell a sleep. I just ate one of them now and I am hiding my other one, for tomorrow. Excellent atmosphere, excellent customer service and excellent sweat tooth saver!