Spitony's Pizza - New Baltimore

Delicious! This is definitely one of my top three pizza places. I highly recommend trying their pizza, subs, and naked wings.

I had the worst pizza experience ever! I truly can't understand how so many people have rated this place positively. The large pizza I ordered had just six pepperoni slices and hardly any cheese—when I received the box, I honestly thought they had forgotten to put the pizza inside! When I tried to pick up a slice, it drooped like a wet noodle. I visited this restaurant on the recommendation of a local, and I regret it. It was truly the worst pizza I've ever had, and I wouldn't return even if they were giving them away! To illustrate what a proper pizza should look like, I've attached a photo of a pepperoni pizza from a place near my home in California.

The pizza here is outstanding and very reasonably priced. I always appreciate the excellent service I receive during my visits! The staff is friendly, and the atmosphere is fantastic. I give it a perfect 10 out of 10 and highly recommend it to anyone. Whenever I have friends visiting from out of town, I always take them here! Keep up the great work, everyone!

Service here is always awesome--friendly and efficient, never have to wait for long. The wings here is a must! Definitely get it breaded! I have never been a huge fan of breaded wings but the way they do it here just adds that nice crunchy texture on the wings. Always cooked perfect!

My wife and I gave it another try and it was better. The pizza, chicken parm sandwich and fried mushrooms were pretty good. Friendly and courteous staff, and most tables were occupied.