Bagel Barn - New Milford

A new start up business should ALWAYS check out the competition. Although the service personnel were cheery, I really wanted to be impressed with another bagel choice in our area. Not the case. As a professional baker for 45 years, I believe the owners need to rethink their product. The bagels are too yeasty, too small, and too expensive.

Bagel barn is such a delicious spot! There’s so many unique flavors of bagels and cream cheese both savory and sweet. The owners are also very welcoming and friendly. Highly recommend the French toast bagel with maple walnut cream cheese. The iced coffee is good too.

Fresh and tasty bagels! I love the unique flavors my favorite is the jalapeño Asiago and Za’atar topped by their homemade vegetable cream cheese. Very attentive staff. Bright space. Great addition to the neighborhood. Definitely a must.

Thank you Bagel Barn! You came to the rescue when my office coffee maker was out of service. The box of coffee and dozen of bagels were AMAZING! My office is still talking about the bagels perfectly cooked and great variety! Great selection of spreads too!

Kudos to the Bagel Barn in New Milford. I was in this past week, I ordered the Diane sandwich for lunch and it was delicious. I had left my debt card behind and even though they were closed for the day Mitch stayed behind so I could swing by and pick it up. Mitch also kindly offered to deliver my card to me as I work close by. Honesty, integrity, and good food, this is what keeps us coming back. Thank you all so much!