Sliced By Harlem Pizza Co

Half of the pizza was missing the red peppers I had requested. Other than that, it was just average. Morningside Heights really struggles to offer great-tasting pizza.

The pizza and garlic knots were just okay, but the chocolate chip cookie was one of the worst I've ever tasted. It resembled an overcooked biscuit and was not sweet at all. I wouldn't recommend the cookie—trust me on that!

Terrible pizza. I wouldn't recommend ordering this at all—you'll likely be very disappointed.

I ordered three slices of pizza from here through Too Good To Go. The cheese was thick and heavy, while the sauce was overly thick and lacked a fresh tomato flavor, tasting more like sugary marinara. Unfortunately, I also experienced diarrhea soon after. Although I'm not entirely sure it was from the pizza, it’s worth noting that the only other food I had was a cream cheese and smoked salmon bagel from a different place, and my three friends who ate bagels as well did not have any issues. While I can't say for certain that the pizza was the cause, it's certainly an important detail. Ultimately, the pizza was quite disappointing, and I cannot recommend it.

I don't get the negative reviews for this restaurant; the chicken parmesan slice is excellent and reasonably priced.