Puzzle Mountain Bakery - Newry

Is it okay to say that I stopped by four of the five days on our vacation? The cookie melt in your mouth. The whoopie pies were a huge hit with the kids. My favorite was the blueberry pie (and jelly). So good. It was fun to stop by a roadside stand while I'm from Maine, my Tampa grandbabies have never seen anything like this. Venmo as an alternative to cash only made it super convenient.

Unbelievable pies, cookies, and jam. Thx for the memories. Our parents lived on this road 50 yrs ago!

Maple cookies were soft and delicious! Also picked up a triple berry pie. Can't wait to eat it!

The cutest pie stand ever! It operates on an honor system, accepting cash and Venmo. We stumbled upon it while driving by and knew we had to stop! We bought a raspberry-strawberry pie and enjoyed it back at our campsite after heating it over the fire—delicious! The maple cookie sandwiches are exceptionally good too! On our way home from the camping trip, we even took a 30-minute detour just to visit the pie stand again and bring some treats home for our families. What a hidden gem!

What a selection! Whoopie pies, cookies, jams, and pies greeted me as I approached. I was instantly hooked and began rummaging through my purse for cash. During my visit, there were classic chocolate whoopie pies, maple cream whoopie pies, cookie sandwiches filled with maple cream, an array of jams, along with Maine Blueberry and Blackberry/Raspberry pies. The sight of those pies was irresistible; I had to take one home because they looked absolutely divine. My past blah experiences with pies faded from memory—after all, they were still warm from the oven! How could I resist a warm pie with a flaky crust filled with luscious berries? The payment here operates on an honor system, and with the cash I had, I walked away with a Blackberry/Raspberry Pie, two Maple Cream Cookies, and a bottle of water. As a long-time fan of Little Debbie's oatmeal creme pies, I found the maple cream cookies to be a million times better. I'm glad I bought two because I devoured one practically immediately. A slice of pie followed five hours later when I got home, and I might just be a pie convert now. My husband declared his slice the best pie he has ever had—ever, which is quite an endorsement! With simple ingredients and loads of flavor, if I'm ever in the area again, I will definitely return. It might even give me a good reason to come back. Don’t miss out on this place; you won't regret it!