Mario's Pizzeria Of Oyster Bay - Feedback

Amazing pizza. Amazing people working there. Always love the fresh plain slice eating in. They cut those pies into 6 slices and it's extra large and fresh. Buff...

First I’d like to begin by saying that this has been my go to pizzeria since 1974 49 years) back when the roller skating rink was where stop and shop is now, an...

Got a Grandma's pizza for takeout. Absolutely delicious.

Ordered 6 large pies to go for a graduation party. Ready on time and delicious as always

Me and my friend went there to eat .. we ordered two slices pizza and one cook ..The guy thought we were new in America like visitors because we are from Georgi...

Best place for pizza in longislande !!!! Service: Dine in Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5

Nice slices. Old school pizza.... olive oil dripping off which is great. None of this coal fired burned crust here. Pizza the way it's meant to be served Servic...

Nice quick and easy for multiple pies. Took card over the phone and got to the destination super fast. Food: 4 Service: 5

Over priced watery drinks with diner food. There’s lots of choices of restaurants on Long Island and this one was checked off our list. Service: Dine in Meal ty...

Very good but the order was delayed. Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $100+ Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 Recommended dishes: Garlic Brea...

The selection of food was a ten, Service was a 8, as they were busy and had to move it along, which they did in an acceptable manner. The pizza was an 8. Pizza...

For rich people ..$28 for entree kidding me that's ok . not great. Been going there since 1980..before they renovated and moved next door .pizza is thick and do...

We come here at least twice a month and the pizza is always fresh and order. a cake comes only in a size that easily feeds two. call them on a Friday Saturday n...

This is the best pizzeria on the long island. The selection of the sorted discs is so good. I love the broccoli wheel. Unbelievable! Very decent Sicilian and ch...

This place was really, really, good. Try a page of meatballs with what you ever eat. Trust me. This is a picture of the meat ball after the fact. I'm sorry I co...

My favorite pizza place anywhere, and that's really saying something after 20 years of living in the NYC metropolitan area. Nobody's buffalo chicken slice comes...

Delicious. ....had a regular slice. ..crispy crust...nice servers. ...clean. ..would definetly go back

Great food and quick and friendly service. The workers were always ready to clear and clean a table for you. Love this place! The best Mario's Pizzeria location...

They make the best pies. We go there with our family a few times a week. Their staff are all so friendly and welcoming so when we walk in it just feels like hom...

We love Marios . Come at least twice a month with the kids

Food was amazing, buyer beware.... HUGE PORTIONS!!! You're definitely getting your money's worth of food! Will be ordering again!

Amazing food. i go there all the time and people are just amazing. especially maxwell, naomy, jerry, kaylah and elias( same name) ! would 100% recommended it he...

Pizza was good however I ordered fresh garlic and got a ton of onions not really the same otherwise good

Awesome pizza! Always follow special requests too! : we love you marios!

Pesto pasta chicken parm roll vry gud