Mark's Pizzeria - Penn Yan

Incredible customer service! The staff went above and beyond to ensure our experience was exceptional. A big thank you to Travis, Darren, and Tiffany!

We really like Mark's Pizzeria! It was a great choice for a quick dinner on a busy night filled with work and other activities. The pizza was tasty, and the buffalo chicken macaroni and cheese was excellent.

As long-time customers of Cam's, we recently received a promotional email from Mark's. After adding a topping, ordering two sodas, and paying for their delivery fee (which, by the way, they do charge), the total came to $12 more than our usual order from Cam's. Unfortunately, the pizza was excessively greasy, the crust lacked flavor, and the pepperoni was burnt, with pools of grease on each slice. I could only manage to eat one slice before tossing the rest. We won't be coming back—definitely a waste of money.

Great pizza! If you love Mark's dough then you already know. If you haven't been, Mark's has some pretty fluffy dough. It's super tasty, great flavor and it's very light. This isn't super NY style if you've every had pizza in NYC but I grew up eating it and love Mark's. I also love the granny's fried dough! Sooo good! I gave this location 5 stars, it had clearly been a long day and the manager/pizza maker was still friendly. Pizza came out great exactly as I had hoped!

We placed an order for 6 pm. The order came early, that was great but the food was not. The onion petals were burned, the chicken fingers on my husband's sub were way over cooked. My calazone was ok, cooked properly but that's about it. I don't usually post reviews but this used to be a great place for take out. I guess I won't order again.