Don Juan - Pleasantville

It took quite some time to get our server’s attention, which we could understand given the holiday and possible staffing shortages. There were two servers in the back dining area and about four runners who could have assisted us while our server was busy. This was the main reason for our drop in rating: the loud music made it difficult to converse, and we were charged for the margarita we never received. Overall, we would consider coming back because the food was excellent, and we hope the service will improve next time.

This authentic Mexican restaurant really captures the vibe you’re seeking! The service is exceptional, and the staff is incredibly attentive. We were treated to complimentary chips and salsa with a generous portion of salsa for the table. For appetizers, we had the quesabirria tacos, which came with three flavorful dipping sauces. I chose the steak fajitas, and the steak was cooked to perfection with a great serving size. I would definitely recommend this place and will undoubtedly be returning!

We recently visited Pleasantville and came across this Mexican restaurant. I recalled that this was an Italian restaurant years ago, so when I found out it had transformed into a Mexican spot, I knew I had to satisfy my taco cravings. The decor was really interesting, the staff was friendly, and the food was quite tasty. I was a bit let down by the limited wine selection, but a refreshing sangria made up for it. Overall, it's a great addition to this charming little town. Enjoy!

The shrimp isn't properly de-veined, the steak is an obliterated overcooked brick, the beans are a runny sludge, the chips are stale and unseasoned, the salsa is devoid of any flavor, and the churros are break-your-teeth rock hard. Don Juan is extremely expensive for exceedingly below-average food.

The guacamole was great. And the drinks were dynamic. Alex the bartender Knows what he's doing. The decor was awesome. Very nice and welcoming feeel