Pleasantville Pizzeria

Delicious pizza! I've visited this place several times and each experience has been wonderful. The owner has a great personality and always treats customers with respect.

This restaurant serves delicious, classic New York-style thin crust pizza and tasty calzones. They offer only a few individual slices (3-4), mainly focusing on whole pizzas priced around $20, with about 25 different options available. The staff is friendly, and there are plenty of indoor and outdoor seating options. They also cater to dietary needs with gluten-free and cauliflower crusts. In addition to pizza and calzones, they offer Italian ice, heroes, wedges, and salads. There is a $15 minimum order for free delivery within Pleasantville. The pizza crust was quite good, boasting a nice crispness when bitten into, although the sauce could use some spices to enhance its flavor. The calzone, generously filled with cheese, was definitely worth the $6.

Paper thin pizza with no taste. Garlic knots that were the size of a dime. I literally had to check the box to make sure there was a pizza inside. Definitely not going back there!!

This could very well be the best pizzeria in Mt. Pleasant. The Sicilian pizza is exceptional, but it can be challenging to place an order after 7:30 or 8:00 as they tend to close early. It's definitely worth making the effort to try again.

Very good Pizza made with attention to detail. Eat in or take out.