Myrtle's Cafe And Pie - Princeton

We found this place by chance as in Princeton from Naperville for grandson's football match. PIE, oh yes! Light flakey chest, many possibilities, all delicious. We bought discs of 4 species that just let us try them all. Friendly staff, charming cafe, a must stop for future trips to the surroundings.

I stopped in tonight for the first time. From a pie aficionado, these pies are legit. The crust is homemade and very flaky. The fillings are very tasty and not skimpy. If you like pie, this is the place to check out!

The Banana Cream and French Silk are amazing!! Can’t wait to get my fix again at Myrtles Pies! Great service and staff too!

This establishment is outstanding. The pie is Devine! The French Silk is true to its name... smooth, luscious and rich. The raspberry cheesecake was rich and pleasing. Our sons are turning into pie fanatics now, too. (They like the DCC and Cake Batter pie) David, the owner is one of the kindest shop owners I have ever met. He has a true passion for making his customers happy and being true to Myrtle's legacy. Shopping small has never tasted better!!

Well worth the drive the pie was delicious and the people were wonderful. The banana cream pie was my favorite.