Pizza Pie Cafe - Rexburg

Pizza was decent. The dessert pizzas were decent as well. The service from the employees were very very good. A recommendation I would suggest is the pizza shelves should be larger and there should be a direction of traffic for the food. It seemed to crowded. The men's bathroom toilet is not attached to the floor on one side causing the whole thing to rock sideways. The men's bathroom floor was wet and that tile is worse than ice when wet.

This place is a decently affordable place to eat dinner however, it's pretty hit or miss. I would say in my most recent trip that about 40% of the pizzas were well over cooked to the point that the dough was as hard as a cracker. And the dessert pizzas were worse. In fact I tried a small slice of each dessert pizza and was only able to finish the cinnamon roll one since all the others were incredibly overcooked. This made the affordable price almost negligible since I wasn't even able to enjoy a large portion of the pizzas. If you want salad the salad bar had a decent variety and at it least won't be burnt.

Really liked the fresh pasta and fresh salad bar. Lots of great choices for a delicious salad. One of the best salad bars in town, especially for the price. Very good selection of pizza toppings. The dessert pizzas are the best! The night we went, I didn't enjoy the as much. The crust seemed a little dry and not very flavorful.

The food was good. And the price was okay. The pizzas were never fully cut so it was a beast trying to get a slice of pizza without touching everything. And no one ever came and grabbed our dirty plates. Also we had a party of over 10 people, and they never offered us a room to sit together. So, when WE asked if there was some where we could sit that all of us would be together, the host gave a vague flick of the hand and didn't help. It looked like a high bar table. But, we had small children and a baby who needed a high chair. So, we had to sit at a bunch of different tables making talking together impossible.

Pizza Pie is always tasty! We especially love the pasta and salads, and obviously the pizza is great too! Things tend to get a bit messy but that's expected. Sometimes the pizza flavor you want isn't up for the entirety of your dining experience which is too bad, but other than that the staff is friendly and great! Would definitely recommend