Tomatoes Italian Grill - Sandwich

This is one of the few places that you can always count on getting a great meal, great drinks, and excellent service. I love the atmosphere, and it's such a bonus that there is live entertainment most evenings. We had eggplant rollatine which was velvety and perfect. I ordered the chicken rollatine for dinner, and that was also just delicious! I think because the food is SO good the desserts don't wow me as much as I hope they will, but it doesn't stop me from ordering a sweet. It is obvious the owners really care about consistency, they care about their customers, and it makes all the difference. Highly recommend!

Touted as the best Italian restaurant on the cape. Not sure that is warranted. Portions are huge. Lots of variety but nothing done exceptionally well. Giant TVs take away from the atmosphere. Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $50–100 Food: 3 Service: 4 Atmosphere: 2

My girlfriend and I went here a while back and had an extremely negative experience. She ordered the Eggplant Napoleon, and I ordered a Caesar Salad and the Bolognese. The lettuce for the salad was old and soggy. The eggplant for her dish was rotten and bitter. My dish was completely covered in what seemed to be a low quality cheese, and overly salty. Neither of us could eat more than 2 bites. We asked our waitress, who was the only highlight of the experience, if we could receive the check and leave due to our food being poor quality. She politely asked if we wanted another dish, which we both declined. Her manager refused to come and visit our table, and when she informed her manager of our experience, we were told by our waitress “our manager says she can’t control people’s food preferences”. I have never in my life sent back food, and I have never written a review for a Restaurant before. However, I would stay away from Tomatoes and would not suggest it to any friends or family looking to get a meal on Cape. Food seemed to be over seasoned, frozen, and microwaved to order. My girlfriend and I will not be returning to this establishment. Payed almost $80 for an inedible meal.

Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $20–30 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 Recommended dishes: Caprese Salad, A Pair Homemade Meatballs, Meatballs and Salad, Arancini, Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail, Steak

Food: Recommend the stuffed meatball florentine. The size of the meatball is massive (about the size of a baby's head), and its stuffed with cheese. Enough easily for two grown people. Very tasty and highly recommend. Otherwise have a large menu. Dessert: The carrot cake slice was massive and very tasty Seating: It is very nice and spacious inside. Not too casual, but not too fancy either. Service: Dine in