Marita's Homemade Ice Cream

Got the Brookie dough and it did not disappoint! Very good. Would come again!

Very poor customer service We went to get water ice. While ordering we were told they were out of a majority of the flavors they had listed on their display windows. The staff noted out of the 8 flavors of water ice displayed they only had bubble gum. We hadn’t tried bubble gum before, and considering we were the only ones in line at the time, I asked to sample a little bit before purchase. Our intentions were to sample bubble gum, and then make a selection on what to get from there. We left empty handed. We were told they don’t do samples, even though this was an error of signage on their part. The demeanor of staff was extremely stand offish, and not accommodating at all. Won’t be back.

Hey, we love you but what’s up with the secret pricing? If prices aren’t visible we can’t give our kids money for your cash only business that is a summer family tradition :

Great little ice cream place in Sea Isle. Lots of options and toppings. Gelato, soft serve, custom mixes, milkshakes and much more. Staff is quick and friendly. Cash only.

Ice cream isn't good and the owner is not a nice person. Treats her employees poorly and makes them feel incompetent at the most basic tasks. Go anywhere else in SIC and you will have a much better experience.