Stony Lake Inn - Shelby

This place is right up my alley. I found this place on accident, I wanted Walleye but I didn't want to go to a fancy yacht club, where I felt uncomfortable. When I walked in with my key bibs on and saw the wood paneling, I knew I was in the right spot.. This little mom and pop dive Is nestled about a half mile or less from the big lake and right next to Stony Lake(sorry for being obvious) It was some of the best walleye I ever had and surprisingly, the best mashed potatoes I've ever had, and I'm Irish. This spot will definitely be my little secret honey hole to surprise friends and family.

The steaks here are fantastic! I’m not sure what the last reviewer experienced, but I’ve never been let down. If there were ever an issue, I’m confident the staff would address it promptly. I’ve been dining at Stony Inn for over 10 years, and I can always count on excellent food and a wonderful staff. I’m also a big fan of the chef salad and their homemade ranch dressing, especially when I’m looking for something light. The broasted chicken is another great choice!

The food was quite tasty, and although the restaurant was really busy, which affected the service, we had a large group. We sincerely appreciate all the effort you put in to make us happy!

We had an amazing experience at this restaurant. The fish was cooked perfectly! Autum was very kind and took excellent care of us. The burgers were also delicious.

Great food! Very nice and friendly place to visit!