Center Cut - Shelbyville

We visited last night, June 4th, 2022, and ordered wine, crab cakes, side salads, two filets, and one ribeye. Unfortunately, the filets arrived as small, overcooked medallion-sized pieces. We had asked for our steaks to be cooked medium and medium rare, but they were served well done instead. While mistakes happen, it took an additional 40 minutes for our new steaks to come out—when it really should have been only about 3-5 minutes per side. By that point, we were quite unhappy and decided to take the food home. No one seemed to care to check in on us or ask how our evening was; they simply handed us the bill. I would recommend steering clear of this place—it doesn’t live up to being a steakhouse.

The steaks were overcooked compared to our request, the mashed potatoes were quite lumpy, and the waitress only inquired about one drink choice. Additionally, she wasn't familiar with the beverage options available at the bar.

I ordered the meatloaf with mashed potatoes and salad for takeout since we were in a hurry. Unfortunately, there was no ranch dressing for the salad, and I suspect the mashed potatoes were instant. The meatloaf was a bit mushy. My friend's NY strip, which was supposed to be medium rare, ended up being closer to medium. He also ordered mushrooms and toppings, but those were omitted. Additionally, we ordered lobster mac and cheese, which they forgot to include in the bag. Thankfully, we used a $100 celebration dinner, or I would have been quite upset about having to pay for that. Overall, the meal was comparable to Mann's Grille.

The service was impeccable! The ribeye was tender, juicy and perfectly cooked, however the lamp chop was tough, chewy and dry. Bit of a disappointment for the price. Won't be getting that again. The drinks were great as well and again, our server was phenomenal! I will return but I'll be sure to get a steak next time.

Located within Indiana Grand Casino, this steakhouse has delicious lamb chops and filet mignon with all the sides you could ever want! The food, expectedly, did take about 30-45 minutes to come to the table which our awesome waitress warned us about when ordering the medium rare lamb chops (average cooking time she said)! Our experience was awesome and albeit on the pricier end, we?ll definitely find a reason to be back for more.