Carvel - South Orange

I absolutely love this place! I've been coming here since high school, and I can't get enough of their classic peanut butter sundae dasher. It’s truly amazing, and the staff is wonderful. I’m glad to be a regular and proud to say this is my favorite ice cream shop! I even brought a girl here for our first date, and now she’s my fiancée—there's something magical about the ice cream!

A dependable and affordable old-fashioned ice cream shop. While it may not be fancy or unique, it fulfills its purpose quite well. They also offer great specials on certain days.

I asked the employee to prepare my ice dessert with wet walnuts and extra whipped cream, without a lid. However, the female server packed my dessert tightly in the cup with a lid, added less whipped cream than I requested, and even overcharged me! It's frustrating to see that these young workers need more training.

Love this place!! It has a kind and friendly atmosphere- when you walk in, you?re greeted with a smile, they have great customer service, the store is clean and serves up some fresh and delicious ice cream. I?ve been coming here with my childhood group of friends for a long time and we will always keep coming back. Reading some of these negative reviews, I feel like they are definitely rare cases because it is not often I see a customer leaving with a frown when they

I ordered a strawberry shortcake ice cream cake for my boyfriend?s birthday and it was by far the best ice cream cake we ever had. I?m not big on writing reviews but I must say it exceeded my expectations. All thanks to Simone who was extremely helpful and responsive. Simone designed the cake beautifully according to my request and the price was affordable. I will definitely be back!