Pagano's Pizzeria - Southold

Dinner was great! The hero specials are typically the best and made fresh to order. The staff was very friendly as well.

Fantastic pizza! The manicotti is excellent too! The chicken Parmesan was delicious! I always recommend them. They consistently deliver in a stylish manner, and the food arrives hot and beautiful every time!

The pizza was huge and possibly the best I've ever had. However, the reason I didn't give this order a 5-star review is that I ordered a BBQ Chicken pizza, which is supposed to come with chicken and BBQ sauce, but it also had onions—a topping I absolutely dislike. I noticed that the SLICELIFE website doesn't mention onions, but other order pages do seem to be accurate. The main website and DOORDASH got it right. I really hope they update the online menu to indicate that this pizza comes with onions so I can avoid them next time. It did put a damper on my experience, but it won't stop me from ordering again; I’ll just be a bit more cautious in the future.

Just had a delicious slice yesterday! Can't understand why the ONE PERSON, who has given a negative rating, is THE ONLY ONLY that has given a negative rating. Sometimes you can't like certain people. The service was great, food was great. Will definitely go back.