Benny's Pizzeria - Stone Ridge

I ordered a Turkey sub. On their website, it says all subs come with lettuce, tomato, onions, and your choice of dressing. I ordered via phone and the kid didn’t sound like he was very smart. These kids that work there literally gave me only a Turkey sub. This was an almost $13 sub. Never even asked if I wanted anything additional. Seriously? Who orders only Turkey on bread???

I really like Benny's pizza. I work in Kingston and I live in Napanoch so I can call on the way home and it's ready just when I hit the halfway point. The only thing to keep in mind is the prices on Google are not accurate. So if you go by that it may be a little higher than you expect.The taste and freshness of ingredients made up for it. Their meat Supreme Is the best around and the staff is always friendly and fast.

Not from the area, but here all the time for biking and climbing. This has become my food stop after. Always have many options for slices, and they still taste fresh after a minute in the oven. Usually has beer options, and other drinks you don't normally see at a pizza joint. Might have to try a grinder next time.

The pizza is alright. They overload the toppings so the cost is a bit higher than I would like to pay for pizza. It's a popular spot amongst the locals. Edit: I'm not bashing locals. I'm stating its a popular place. Ask anyone in town they will rave about your pizza place and how the toppings are overloaded

Best pizza hands down! My whole family loves this place! We have to bring pizza with us to Massachusetts every time we visit my brother lol