Godfather's Pizza - Surf City

Do not buy Dip here! $10 higher on the roll than across the road!

Amazing young man took our order an fixed our pizzas. Food was ready fast an super hot! Tasted fantastic! It was our first time

Godfather's is inside Handy Mart. The employee was friendly and prompt. Pizza was good, as usual.

Okay so don't let the fact that it's in a gas station. Turn you away! The pizza places were packed on the island so I decided to give them a chance. The service was quick and the pizza was so good! The kids approved!

Absolutely awful experience. Ordered pizza, waited over 20 minutes. One of the workers told us the pizza would be done in a minute, just to find out 10 minutes later it was never started. There’s was about 5 employees standing around including the manager. No one offered a refund or apologized. Go here if you want to waste your time.