Dicarlo's Pizza Wellsburg

Pizza was decent, but they have the crispy height. Very good. You were happy where you were. It's just that.

I liked the pizza to a boiled French bread that has a soggy crust with cheese pepperoni that feels like it had been thrown up *to* bake. If you take the pizza home and cook it at 375-400F in a toaster oven for 6-10 minutes, the crust will be firm and crispy, the paprika cracks a little, and the cheese tastes right. Do this if you want to upgrade to a 3-star experience, but the family nostalgia forces you to order from here. If you want a really good pizza, you are probably better off the order from somewhere else BEFORE you visit Wellsburg.

Been going to this DiCarlo's for over 40 years. I no longer get live in the area, but every time that I am close I stop in and stock up. Today I drove in from Cleveland to pick up 100 pieces to take back to Lawrenceburg, IN. It was a 200 mile detour but it is always worth it. Tim and his guys maintain the same high standards that I saw 40 years ago. Still waiting for Tim to bring me some when he visits his relatives in Cincinnati. Ate a whole box on the drive home.

Love, love, love!! This place has been owned by the same people for 20+ years. Everytime I get their pizza, it is amazing! It's clean, friendly, efficient. Nothing negative at all.

Have heard nothing but awesome things about this place from people who live around here. Finally got the chance to check it out..ordered 45 minutes before closing. Two large pizzas (28 slices). And it was unanimous...it was the worst pizza we have ever had!! Watched them take it out of the over and then delivered 7 minutes down the road and pizza was cold!! Both pizzas we're bland and with hardly any sauce, very dry. Ordered extra pepperoni, and got two pieces of pepperoni on each slice. The banana peppers were good on the? second pizza, however, this is the only thing we could say for it. To add salt to the wound the total for these two pizzas was $100!! I guess you never know until you try...now we know. What a disappointment..