Nypd Pizza - Winter Garden

Can not go wrong for a quick pie at NYPD Pizza. Crew here is nothing less than professional with their service. I ordered a Queens Deluxe and was able to swap out green peppers for green olive. No one flinched or cringed. They smiled and said ok. Pie came out piping hot and delicious! I love NYPD Pizza...and NYPD Greek Salad...

I have only been here once a few years ago but decided to give it a shot again through Uber Eats. Ordered the Patrolman Pepperoni Calzone and Bone-in Wings. The calzone was mediocre. I can't really say anything bad about it but can't really say anything good about it either. I didn't love the flavor of the pepperoni itself and the sauce that was on the side was pretty basic. It was fairly large which made it a decent value for the price. I was more bothered that the wings were wrong. The order was for bone-in wings but instead I was given breaded boneless wings. Definitely wasn't what I wanted, which were basically over breaded chicken nuggets. I tend to order hot Buffalo wings but the hot sauce here was quite hot. I imagine the soaked thick breading had more sauce which probably made it seem hotter. All in all, there's much better pizza places in the area. I wasn't impressed the first time which is why I hadn't gone back, but this delivery I think was enough for me to realize that I should just keep to the other places in the area.

I have enjoyed NYPD Pizza a couple of times over the holiday season. Both times it was for pick up orders with multiple pies. The pies were freshly made and taste great. The chicken ranch and bbq chicken was a crowd favorite but I especially liked the Buffalo chicken pizza. It had moist chicken, wing sauce, mozzarella cheese and a light drizzle of blue cheese dressing. It was mild and very tasty. Ordering was easy and the restaurant was clean.

This review hurts me to write as this used to be the only pizza place we ordered from. NYPD Pizzeria was my go to order when I wanted tasty and authentic NY Style pizzas, calzones, and strombolis. My last 2 out of 3 orders using Door Dash from NYPD Pizza have been terrible. Two times, the Swat Team Stromboli has been undercooked. Literally raw dough on the inside of the stromboli. As for the calzones, the cheese was barely melted on the inside. In addition, I ordered everyone desserts. New York Cannoli Soggy and inedible Oreo Zeppoles Super oily and tasted like old stale frying oil Brooklyn Stuffed Zeppoles Same as above All of the desserts were inedible. The first time, I gave them a pass as I can understand errors can occur. This time I felt compelled to write a review to hopefully allow them to address their issues.

I was shopping in the area I decided to order a small cheese pizza to go from NYPD Pizzeria in winter garden. First I would like to say the crust was absolutely amazing I mean it was just like I was back in Manhattan From there it went downhill. I know the picture May reflect otherwise but there was an extreme lack of sauce and cheese on this pizza I mean I seriously felt like all I was eating was the crust I was so excited to try their pizza from the pictures on yelp but in true life it did not reflect the same. Was very disappointed . They have locations in Tampa and our office used to order from them every once in awhile and the pizza was absolutely amazing and had plenty of sauce and an abundance of cheese not sure what happened here. I would seriously eat here again just for the crust but I guess maybe next time ask for extra cheese and extra sauce .